Best sugar cookie recipe to make masterpieces!

The best sugar cookie recipe is at your fingertips.

What makes the perfect sugar cookie to you?

Is it the velvety texture? Is it the soft thickness? No brown bottoms? Oh, how about the taste that hits every feel good bone in your body?

If so, here is that best sugar cookie recipe below.

This will save you oodles of time and 'sifting' through a great many recipes!

As a primer, be sure to check out this page: How to Make Professional Cookies.

The best sugar cookie recipe that's super delicious and made for decorating

Does starting your own sugar cookie business and selling them excite you? Then you need a solid foundation to build on.

That foundation begins with the best sugar cookie recipe baked the right way.

After all, what good is a masterpiece atop an average or less than average base?

You don't have to necessarily buy name brands or expensive products either.

I have tested name-brand items against store-brand ones.

Results?

I prefer some products with store-bought brands.

Two important keys:

  1. Real butter. Period.
  2. Emulsion, not extract

Here is the list of ingredients:

·         Walmart’s Great Value flour (or Kroger)

·         Walmart’s Great Value sugar (or Kroger)

·         table salt, usually Great Value

·         any brand of eggs

·         cream cheese, usually Great Value (or Kroger)

·         emulsions, LorAnn 

The least expensive way to buy emulsion is by the gallon. Here is a link to the best-tasting emulsion I've found. It's perfect for these sugar cookies! There are a variety of sizes if you do not want to go all in for a gallon!


LorAnn Butter Vanilla Bakery Emulsion, 1 Gallon

LorAnn Butter Vanilla Bakery Emulsion, 1 Gallon
9.5/10 WeCookier's Golden Cookie Award
  • LorAnn's Butter Vanilla Emulsion lends the rich taste of butter plus vanilla to all of your baked goods and frostings. Try it in your recipes as a substitute for regular vanilla extract. For those who are familiar with the flavor of Butavan - this emulsion is for you!
  • 1 teaspoon baking extract = 1 teaspoon emulsion
  • Water Based ( Soluble in Water)
  • Kosher - Gluten Free - Made in USA
Check Price
As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases
Emulsion flavoring for baking. Makes the flavor pop instead of extracts that bake out of the food.Example of emulsion flavorings and sizes

That’s it? Yep. Super easy!

Wait! What in the world is the 'e' word again? Oh yes, emulsion.

The texture of the emulsion is a thick but pourable solution that is water-based. Since it doesn't have alcohol-like extracts, most of the flavor will stay in during baking.

Extracts have their place in frostings and icings. Though people do use emulsion in them as well. I do not since emulsion is expensive. I choose to use clear pure Mexican vanilla in its stead in royal icing. 

This is a good article on the Imperial Sugar website for a close look at using pure vanilla vs imitation.

I purchase Danncy's clear pure Mexican vanilla from Amazon in a pack of 3. The flavor is unbeatable! I heard one cookier say she didn't like it and that it was so strong. It is strong. It tastes a little like almonds even, though it doesn't contain almonds. It just requires using less. Believe me...

...it does NOT disappoint!

This Amazon affiliate image link below is 1/4 of the cost when buying a 4-pack. You can find the single bottles there as well.

4 X Danncy Clear Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract From Mexico 33oz Each 4 Plastic Bottle Lot Sealed

4 X Danncy Clear Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract From Mexico 33oz Each 4 Plastic Bottle Lot Sealed
9.5/10 WeCookier's Golden Cookie Rating
Check Price
  • Danncy Pure Vanilla Extract From Mexico 4 Plastic Bottle Lot Sealed.
  • Info from the bottle: does not contain: coumarin.
  • (Net 33 fl. oz. each) four new sealed bottles.
  • Four clear bottles listed.

Stay on 'track'...sign up for the WeCookiers Express periodical. Click on the train!

Sign up for the We Cookiers Express newsletter for tips, hacks videos and tutorials. Hop on the cookie train and get the best sugar cookie recipe!We Cookiers Cookie Train Express Newsletter Sign Up

The best sugar cookie recipe...' soft, durable, tasty'

This is a straightforward, no-fuss-no-muss sugar cookie recipe.

Soft, durable, and tasty. Did I mention a wonderfully velvety texture?

Look for yourself…

This recipe makes thick, soft, and tasty cookies
Image of completed sugar cookies from the best sugar cookie recipe.

These photos indicate the thickness and velvety look of these tasty cookies.

There are photos below for a step-by-step process.

Here is the best sugar cookie recipe you’ll find.

This recipe is made available to you through the download link below—FREE.

Nita’s Signature Sugar Cookies

Ingredients

2 sticks (1/2 pound) of real butter, room temperature

4 oz. cream cheese, room temperature

1 whole egg, room temperature

1 ½ c granulated sugar

1 tsp almond emulsion

1 tsp butter-vanilla emulsion

1 tsp salt

3 c flour

This makes roughly 20, 3” cookies.

Free 'Best Sugar Cookie Recipe'. Download and print for yourself!Click image for your FREE 'Best Sugar Cookie Recipe' download. You won't regret it!

This is my Superior Royal Icing Recipe that couples deliciously with these sugar cookies! Click to take you to the recipe.

The Superior Sugar Cookie Icing recipe you do not want to miss! Yummy and easy to make. Couple it with the cookie recipe on WeCookiers.com and you have a winner.Superior Sugar Cookie Icing Recipe

Click this image below for a great sugar cookie glaze recipe as a free download as well:

Image link for a free sugar cookie glaze recipeSugar Cookie Glaze link

***If you are comfortable with the recipe and eager to get started decorating, click this image to start the royal icing flooding process.

If you are ready to start pricing your cookies to sell, click this link.

Royal icing flooding is the start of your 'art with a cookiers heart'. If you are eager to get started coating your cookie, let's go! https://www.wecookiers.com/royal-icing-flooding.htmlRoyal Icing Flooding directions

What are the best attributes of this sugar cookie recipe?

  • easy
  • quick
  • delicious
  • perfect for cut-out cookies
  • won't spread 
  • stays soft after baking for up to 2 weeks in an airtight container
  • freeze dough for months
  • freeze undecorated baked cookies for months
  • bakes flat
  • makes customers happy

*These cookies should be chilled for 15 minutes or overnight. If it is overnight, you will need to let the dough set out for a bit to make it workable or it will be brick-hard.

I have used it with just a few minutes being chilled before you use your cutters. You need it workable but not soft.

Directions (stand mixer or hand mixer)

1.       Cream butter and cream cheese together until it looks fluffy and light yellow.

2.       Add egg, granulated sugar, and emulsions. Mix just until incorporated.

3.       Add the salt and flour. Mix only until the flour is mixed in. Over-mixing could cause tough cookies due to the egg.

4.       Spatula it out onto plastic wrap on a table. Form a nice ball. Flatten the ball out to a rectangle or disk shape about an inch high.

It doesn’t matter the height. The more you flatten it out in this soft stage, the less you have to roll it out with your rolling pin. Also, flattening the dough into discs makes them perfect to stack.

5.       Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap. I double the plastic wrap if the dough will be in the fridge for more than a couple of days. Place it in the fridge for 15 minutes or overnight.


Step-by-step instructions of how to make the best sugar cookie recipe:

Sugar cookie ingredients.Step 1 Gather ingredients
Step 1. Begin by adding butter and cream cheese.Step 2 Add butter and cream cheese to bowl
Step 3. Creaming together butter and cream cheese.Step 3 Beat butter and cream cheese til light and fluffy
Step 4. Add sugar, emulsions, and egg.Step 4 Add egg, sugar, and emulsions
Step 5. Raise mixer paddle after wet ingredients are mixed.Step 5 Lift paddle/beater to add dry ingredients
Step 6. Add salt and flour on top of wet mixture.Step 6 Add flour and salt on top of wet ingredients
Step 7. Mix flour and salt just until flour disappears. Do not over-mix.Step 7 Scrape bowl and paddle/beater
Step 8. Spatula out the dough mixture onto plastic wrap.Step 8 Spatula out the dough onto plastic wrap
Step 9. Form the dough into a ball.Step 9 Form dough into a ball
Step 10. Flatten the dough on plastic wrap into a disc shape.Step 10 Flatten dough ball into a disc shape about 1/2" thick
Step 11. Wrap the dough disc tightly in plastic wrap.Step 11 Tightly wrap dough disc in plastic wrap
Doug disc should be around 1/2" thick.Roughly 1/2" thick

6.        When chilled, sift out some flour on your workstation. Place dough on the flour and roll out. I choose to cut them at ¼” thickness. All of my customers just love these thick and soft cookies!

7.       Cut out the shapes and place them on these highly-rated affordable cookie sheets.

8.       Place the cookie sheet in the freezer. Allow freezing completely to prevent spreading when baked.

9.       Preheat the oven to 350⁰.

10.   When cookies are frozen, pull them out of the freezer and place them immediately into the oven, yes frozen. Bake for 13 minutes. For a softer cookie yet, remove cookies just before they are finished baking. They will continue to bake after you take them out.

Place chilled dough on floured work stationStep 1. Place dough on floured work station
Dough rolled out to prepare for cutting out cookiesStep 2. Roll dough out to a quarter of an inch
Dough rolled out to a quarter of an inchPhoto showing cookie dough rolled out to a quarter of an inch
Cut out cookies spaced on cookie sheetPhoto of spacing and thickness of cookies on cookie sheet.

I use Nordic Ware cookie sheets with parchment. When I take them out of the oven, I just leave the cookies to cool on the same pan on my baker’s rack. They never get a browned bottom.

Bonus: saves an extra step!

Best sugar cookie recipe...you need to know these details and tips

Make sure they are cooled before you begin making your works of art.

These sugar cookies will last up to 2 weeks easily on the counter in an air-tight container.

Oh—did I say the cookie is delicious without any icing or frosting?

I have customers who prefer just the cookie, they are that good! The cookie itself isn't all that sweet. The sweet royal icing on top levels out the extra sweet taste so double win.

Be sure to tap for my favorite—no-fail—sugar cookie icing recipe, aka: Superior Royal Icing

There you have it. The best sugar cookie recipe.

The We Cookier's Express periodical sign-up: the Express will stop at your inbox once a month (usually up to five days grace period on either side of the first). 

What's in it? Inspiration, cookie-cutter flip ideas, marketing your business, business building, Q&a, etc. Obviously, something you will look forward to opening. Oooh and freebies here and there! This is all you need to fill out and you are an instant free WeCookier member!

Top of Best Sugar Cookie Recipe

Some of my most popular pages here:

Projector for Cookies image linkProjector for Cookies link
Airbrushing Cookies image linkAirbrushing Cookies link
Best Baking Sheets image linkBest Baking Sheets link
Silk Screen Cookie Decorating image linkSilk Screening Cookies link
Best Buttercream Frosting image linkBest Buttercream Frosting link
Edible Cookie Images linkEdible Cookie Images link