10 PYO cookie palette ideas. Which is the winner? Curious? Watch video!

PYO Cookie Palette.

These are among the many cookie decorating techniques.

This page offers an in-depth look at 10 ways to make a PYO cookie palette. I’ll show you the successes and failures of each as I place them ‘under the microscope’ to see which is the best and/or worst.

Scroll down the page if you want to go right to the video.

10 ways to make a PYO cookie palette:

Near the bottom of the page, you can see a clear picture of all these side by side.

- Skittles

- M&Ms

- pipe and airbrush royal icing dots

- airbrush dots on cookies with stencil

- paint royal icing dots

- use gel to paint dots on cookies

- food color markers

- use an edible printer

-use a program like Microsoft Word

-paint pods

This page covers 10 ways, but the 11th method would be:

- order pre-made store color palettes

About each of the compared PYO cookie palettes…

1. Skittles, easy, fast, no cleanup. However, you can see they did do some color bleeding in the royal icing after 2 days.

Image of using skittles for a palette

2. M&Ms are easy, fast, and no cleanup too. Just flood your cookie and place the candies in the wet flood icing. Let them dry. Done. Note the green, brown, and orange color bled as well after 2 days.

Using M&Ms for a cookie palette

3. Airbrushing royal icing dots is easy, pretty fast, and has some cleanup. Pipe royal icing dots, let dry overnight, and airbrush them the next day.

Image of airbrushed royal icing dots

4. An even easier way for your PYO cookie palette with airbrushing is simply using a stencil with circles. This is much faster than airbrushing piped dots. Fast. Some cleanup.

Image of airbrushed circles on cookie

5. Painting royal icing dots is the same as airbrushing. With these though, you paint the royal icing dots with food color gel mixed with either Vodka, Ever-Clear, or Lemon Juice (don’t worry, the alcohol evaporates). You then paint the color on the dots. Not so easy, messy, and cleanup needed. Time-consuming as well.

Image of painted royal icing dots with food gel

6. Using food color gel to paint the dots on a flooded and dried cookie is another way.

Painting the color on the sugar cookies is easy, fast, cheap, and not much cleanup.

There is one caveat, however. The gel food color on a cookie is pretty concentrated. It will not taste good and also leaves the mouth stained.

I am an Americolor person myself. I love their bright and rich colors. This is not an affiliate link, but I purchase all of mine from Country Kitchen Sweet Art. The benefit of ordering through them is the shipping is $5.99 to free! Not to mention they are a super company.

Image of painting food gel and vodka right on cookie

7. I came up with the idea of coloring a palette with food color markers. Easy, no mess.

Image showing food color markers colored on the cookie palette

8. Using an edible copier to make a PYO cookie palette is easy if you have a Cricut or Silhouette, or the like.

Simply go into the design program, make a rectangle and add however many circles you want for a palette. Change the circle colors to your preference. You will want to aim to get the deepest colors though. If you choose lighter colors, you won’t be able to see them very well after painting the cookie.

Connect the shapes with the attachment tool in the program, then make them.

If you are including these in a customer’s order, always put your business name on the palette before printing. Branding is super important.

After you have the PYO cookie palette in the program, it is fast, easy, and has no cleanup.

Image of edible image cookie palette

9. Use a program like Microsoft Word. If you are familiar with Word, setting up a cookie palette is similar. Once it is set up, you’ll always have it. You can also make various color palettes.

How is this edible though? All you need to do is copy off the palette into an edible printer on white cardstock paper.

Why would you want to use Word instead of a design program? At least in the Cricut Design Space, they have a few colors to choose from that are vibrant/deep. Word is limitless since you can use hex numbers.

Brand those babies! Remember to place your cookie business logo on the palettes for extra exposure to your customers. Not to mention, it's much more professional. 

Read more about branding to grow your business here at Talkroute. I'm not a member, I just found the article helpful in stressing the importance of branding.

Microsoft Word works well for paint palettes. Check out this extensive video on many methods for them.

10. Paint pots/pods are a good alternative and are what I’ve used for a good while now. You can find the empty pods on Amazon. I take a syringe and fill them with the gel color mixture.

They are super because you can clip the line anywhere between the pods. They come in strings of 6 and if you wanted to offer 3 colors, well you just doubled the amount from 240 pots to 480--that's significant savings!

Image of empty paint pods to use instead of palette

11. This is not in the video or above, but it is another way. Sorry, I've never bought them so I couldn't speak about them.

Premade cookie palettes. This goes without saying. No cleanup, no mess, fast, easy.

The con about these is they are expensive when you take into account shipping. For just a dozen you'll find they run over $12. with shipping. That's a LOT to add to a cookie order.

PYO cookie palette comparison results in photos

1. Skittles

Image of the results of using skittles for a PYO cookie palette

2. M &  M's

Image showing the result of using M&Ms for a cookie paint palette

3. Piping and airbrushing royal icing dots

Image showing result of using piped and airbrushed royal icing dots

4. Airbrushing circles on cookies

Image showing the result of using the airbrushed circles on a cookie

5. Painting the piped royal icing dots by hand with a gel mixture

Image showing the result of using food gel painted royal icing dots for a palette

6. Painting the gel mixture right onto the cookie

Image showing the result of painting the gel and vodka right on the cookie for a PYO cookie palette

7. Food color markers

Image showing the result of using food color markers for a PYO cookie palette

8. Using an edible copier

Image showing the result of using an edible image for a palette

9. Microsoft Word on heavyweight paper or cardstock

Image showing the result using Microsoft Word printing with edible ink on paper

10. Paint pods. Sorry, no photo for this, but it turns out the very same as the other 2 methods of using the gel mixture.

Image showing you can use paint pods instead of a cookie palette

Here are the final results, side-by-side.

Image shows all 10 comparisons for the PYO cookie palettes

Keep in mind, that PYO cookies are simply a form of water-coloring since you will be using water. This form, no matter the medium you use, will not be deep and dark colors, though a few of them are darker than others.

I hope this has helped you decide which PYO cookie palette to use.

Top of PYO Cookie Palette

Food Color Markers image link
Cookie Stenciling image link
Enjoy We Cookiers? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.